I assume your moving them to the mum folder using a filter. If Thunderbird side, that filter runs before junk clasification by default. If server side you would need to consult your mail provider.

Now Junk status should not occur if the address is in your address book. Is it? Secondly open one of the mail using CTRL+U look in the headers (the bit of code stuff before the message) for anything that says SPAM, or words with spam in them.

Copy and paste that part of the header to a reply here on the forum and perhaps we can work out what is happening.

Hi Matt-thanks a million for your reply to my posting.

I will only be able to look at the header tomorrow because I'm not with my PC today and I don't have Thunderbird on my Mac here.

Re: the address book; yes, the address is in the address book. Re: the filter...I haven't changed any rules or filters in months and yet the flagging of the messages as Junk is only recent; so my Q. is "how can this be a result of any filters if the rules/filters have been there pre-the problem existing"?

I need to check for sure whether the emails arrive in the Inbox and I then move them to my mum's folder, or whether they arrive directly in my mum's folder...I may need till Monday to test this but may be able to let you know tomorrow.

I will be back in touch....thanks again!

Hi Matt-I am pasting 2 separate headers below (in 2 separate response boxes); one is an email from me to my mother (I always bcc: myself into all emails) an another is to another recepient (not my mother, but this email was also marked Junk). I have removed the content of the email that is personal, as well as both email addresses. I don't see the words Spam in either email header, though there is reference to an error (SPF) in one of these email headers.

If you can make sense of any of this, I'd be grateful.

X-Apparently-To: "X"; Fri, 05 Jun 2015 07:30:13 +0000 Return-Path: <X X-YahooFilteredBulk: 65.20.0.12 Received-SPF: pass (domain of btinternet.com designates 65.20.0.12 as permitted sender) X-YMailISG: 2KwqOcMWLDv_Nu_Df9L0hE52_Q9JgXzTy3w5PJuk_0mNxwU6 <pre>n86b4E3xDgfJEvUdZdaRGnXu8tgnVMxQh3Sa4SnzZ.iLci7vEWHizKA2Nbox isKgbHF_Ge6_Q5Kh63LmsYbpBJYr1rfGhnJ7B8AHzZjJZJySQr0ir7vqe6Eg yzx4ymfUfykeTkFICpNrXPq86GrhIEk1mXsDmRGxX63Zz3H7683XnMxtCheb _sOMEk9fuMiFOhlgqdVwIwN_KufplqZ6k8mLPl2tFAmI_ewsTJa4JvPdBskN ltQP91ZUB8Np5af8AxsJDcZ4jGcgV6Xcq9zWXJhxL1t_zkwX7sYaR779Z95f b.ERu7Olisl27QCw8f9n6eBpx1q5Ba1km0sPL_YM5MG.o03XXy0CjYCekfs6 gWTQKi.oO8zf7RzbeWw4o52Qod8BLDlY6hcahMRwDt34.rr18MAUmMRf3ES1 KncOtifFmif0hJKaJ0KALF2MWJxdJGjV7b1WdM1_L1RbsNl9vnXu5DmEaClM rZUAEZ2Qo6nF1rS167_BpN_VgnAk8kXLspnZW7zXrnIlsihrKWW8q1SDbABW s0J7m.rGlq41NlE4ftQFts7AwN9NBcHQyG9.g.synyPe5OCv1jhGkVJadJjZ CuGBiXSbnJtxSS99xsQ5JKUqrZf9fIn0.WgldKwKfu.t5_9ggazp3f.6K76L _Ck578Xktyz30D18.HlMhsHuUa_7kfSly1TJC67TkqH8RvYnmO_bszdIqyoT XXHjnPkJOh47KETbx2g2naxUGV5tWuZPRj5rc8r9GBFp16tz7ecaVRtcPXXd kA8_17m9CBkg6i7TpaXKrb3oEDaW2pFcFbCcRkTypmtlp2gFLUdx7ZAJarma 8VZLF0devwbcSVmfVIZ2svLziB5o2.tFKEDScXGx4onVBqr4kngOPyDzzTkC ODBNyOg3TJouLpQ3JNnmDCPPFMbD.zqGUUFn_5TgTfXje7hN4sVinUcvof3p iUZITG29deTX1q5Unbq8yFtAAbvpw7y6.1tpatCHTYo0L4pj.byMpqGjNsV7 tRqxzJu76rMOAF5HRQo9I25.KWwdSXzQzV.v0EWJP36IJeQ5WutnAEIDrSyJ 5KvEsLj17T24ETpH5RpedssIsjA65EIhpYgLAGyLlODb2jbT6Is2XG13uEB. qXMIUljFeD5va62IlomhBeDU8dSsGUFso7qqJuvId0NVVMiXd3CT5VhUkK.N WHQraCpSXXgm7i2Tr3qBKUudN7N.SF23ebBry6h1WWP25lHdQi6mGZAR1ZRm oXHovxnKC.JqZVEv38ZH7Y7I_MU560UXpE.jgFDF3Lk8qcz0

X-Originating-IP: [65.20.0.12] Authentication-Results: mta1023.bt.mail.ir2.yahoo.com from=; domainkeys=neutral (no sig); from=btinternet.com; dkim=pass (ok) Received: from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO rgin09.bt.ext.cpcloud.co.uk) (65.20.0.12)

 by mta1023.bt.mail.ir2.yahoo.com with SMTP; Fri, 05 Jun 2015 07:30:12 +0000

X-OWM-SPF-MAILFROM: Pass X-OWM-Source-IP: 212.82.97.177(GB) X-OWM-Env-Sender: X X-CTCH-RefID: str=0001.0A0B0203.55715004.01D0,ss=1,re=0.000,recu=0.000,reip=0.000,cl=1,cld=1,fgs=0 X-CTCH-VOD: Unknown X-CTCH-Spam: Unknown Received: from nm40-vm9.bullet.mail.ir2.yahoo.com (212.82.97.177) by rgin09.bt.ext.cpcloud.co.uk (8.6.122.06)

       id 55701EFD0282CD7E for X; Fri, 5 Jun 2015 08:30:12 +0100

DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=btinternet.com; s=s2048; t=1433489412; bh=wQuBx0UaEEwKeZEkq0ZzL08P2TLl34+a1RdaRBt0gz8=; h=Date:Subject:From:To:References:In-Reply-To:From:Subject; b=EkKP28GTsLke3txk9vF/ou3oiKJ9kDnZA2Fhq0TculWlji3MJJe2TrYUZ9IsU1JieW6aQ0dS+lYdABGctlcYN0K/u0evOdaGb+4psl8uidwuCK3eRnRkBEiEbNpz8kT3HqJsNM+h4uBLVx1a/gDHfS5xW14sn4CXNuNHtI25ICYC95M01kperQQ4IZwNtEvT206sgUKYSOwUtcMrZkWAmBECTqNn3i5Fe3a/VARd6MOLWh8cNBwo7r7s8LlWYOrSkU13AA1bg+3XbS6PRvSfydIwNhHsFY1MgvDZpTVdjctrXncxKe4wlgylpU+wZiwkKpfkVacJrZpmYQtkWRdfZw== Received: from [212.82.98.56] by nm40.bullet.mail.ir2.yahoo.com with NNFMP; 05 Jun 2015 07:30:12 -0000 Received: from [46.228.39.97] by tm9.bullet.mail.ir2.yahoo.com with NNFMP; 05 Jun 2015 07:30:12 -0000 Received: from [127.0.0.1] by smtp134.mail.ir2.yahoo.com with NNFMP; 05 Jun 2015 07:30:12 -0000 X-Yahoo-Newman-Id: 302842.65830.bm@smtp134.mail.ir2.yahoo.com X-Yahoo-Newman-Property: ymail-3 X-YMail-OSG: 9AeQrsAVM1lS759_lwHjp6FSY73BNJW78__bVu8de9Icwk8

_ZAYSNEK4Wzy62u.TLBsjnLjKV9QGPQqq2oX5UQ4gZjMlUZZOeXI90nl43Zi
9_kues.8TFvw9LitmrR._NDP12vwAGksxS1Cs8jQ9ZPim0fNePCk8CaWvqEA
_9EUX6HbAh54w2HYDYRFu71OJ1EiBZKWix5c0LCZPPoCk0STlqEiY6XEGuLc
9aDXPzVecaaLJBoMNI0NjlLYu3ZhswjSftKVbWzTHza2s61XaCOGTh5WIYXu
dLy.qIYUJ8djmYBoyVkbyGnomhUbR9Q7jyvbFCDY9nKafk5w3PXgnlWL7M8a
5UUuxL9M2spLzUPehkTMk5fonlIb7NIgGfhQ9hd15LkcOvpFii3ggDP3gVKv
8LtANepWcyqCMbed7CCV2jccDiw888PZ3G_RTGyRiJ1YJTvDnZcPuzdbSw2N
DQD3ZQzLuEQzsvwJJ05oBTeDzEhtxc7YgptpRhxoz0TwqM_NbgPn0b2csPWC
v6d2qzns5jGB_7GAzMRp_UytLfn3LFEwQ9a93p_MDMeNDy0WJTx7A_5c-

X-Yahoo-SMTP: siU_3lOswBDdHIwsjoD7FApMm2ot9u3Pya36jQr7X9nfHD8qfw-- User-Agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/15.8.0.150303 Date: Fri, 05 Jun 2015 08:29:58 +0100 Subject: Re: seeking photo albums.... From: To: Message-ID: <[email protected]> Thread-Topic: seeking photo albums.... References: <[email protected]>

<[email protected]>

In-Reply-To: <[email protected]> Mime-version: 1.0 Content-type: multipart/alternative; boundary="B_3516337805_1570778777" Content-Length: 12305

Here is the other header from an email I sent to my mum:

X-Apparently-To: X Thu, 04 Jun 2015 15:16:33 +0000 Return-Path: <X> X-YahooFilteredBulk: 65.20.0.12 Received-SPF: permerror (encountered permanent error during SPF processing of domain of bell.net) X-YMailISG: 3MWJuZMWLDu39zhX54xPkepyDTGpwGx4nEsgMaRgMBL.PFkq

UPEZnJFnD1vmleO4fcF83X3QHL.hgniiVUZCWGFmwI2i9MQ9f9Mb8eklUYCI
gu6klYNH5yZUIj3An515nbY3TFh6XW1G9p5B3Dn1LkyFs7zwc4ZS5btnMZZd
olI2mN1sJojrhuFzrl9lfEfoeJkiDTNOGzvKKGE1DzWUMxo1JZaGObGwHIBa
jgP0Kl3f0I3J.p9OKuZOszcYQqsGsRr_TURNaEHc6k0ks2zBRKWzgJ0cbDBc
M4A4AjM87DOYGtUupmFd1Y_6cefNk.0mXXClzggtIIi4CUnPDm5FZwtq6p4v
Rg.xJGzf985iZsxnftsfWoFYyz0cU1BIF6pXR8OfINN_DkfLcCbofnnuUma_
tW75UqvTGGyUorwGqq0XB5KXR3eu0h1YkW0spgTA.dNrzdf7V9eABC8rnprj
p_g_vJqzTrBwS6T_IBHNN66R._IUxtErDJsQ1I08zBGnMn2f5JKozk.2Wxkl
3Fj47dNzko_ydEOR6tJ9NQ3OKxCRu4Lg6zzNppDeAWWQ0SoHvA6tLAuR1OOg
7qfmS5Kq1MIju1GjwnfV.hhlLWWk3hcecrXHC4gVBovB8BShXN2rOcr0EY0_
EcfiNe.OFaLaQ0ZqD9AlyG5tBlKhfcVU_YwgT_RWI7JqWSyF1_Jrm05lP.ik
l63GrSHCbOacigX_FPIe0LgUIcDDX6b8qjWFa0sDHZI23ShBVbraunVn_Jk8
jxRvPLlX1D7CBO0ppiblD.WGEZmpAz0mYczrfyS7L6WAxW18C.kUJ307svNu
P6viyyhhqNX.L6HGbsSzhQEVcpKuMKjg9BmPs88CzYAP6bQ8tsPFU7zd_R_F
g.UjaEJg8tzurRaFZuDLwsF88wZko._04n91OVDVwz5bFvGpfRop.oiuyyRb
82NhJgF1sxVbXT1ImoV4qzhZI6Yr1AfD7f7kNpbdWc2.lzndYxSidnL4sRUm
VvN2LM7mGPAcDkCGHHkfF14bu2yNyTzHVsI0.FRdO0Seq65WYeTYKybEq1HQ
i3iyPt6.khEjWB5jsA0auttMfS0FyIdlFMyWyMcK2Mxb2GWQVQRp_d7BsNRS
Ji.7UiHUi8ctHhqY9D1HhnHftgnqgbHvdCB0TjSlZLCChdoLQqyQXC8vDloV
AZ6xL3lq0ZflPbjOyxlQooWcQvj457eK12f8C8F4ZxgITmIzT2mTpxad14df
zO66Wr7IPye.kZFvZA7tlEIIDMaDs834G71V9qVSlU4fHisgk4aes_EZlrRQ
g3RYvcVC_9wlNP87FNNSOcp8D8Qc6kUuu7Ug_R8URrv4soMpuFFCLWK9OtRq
uk_EmvEx

X-Originating-IP: [65.20.0.12] Authentication-Results: mta1002.bt.mail.ir2.yahoo.com from=; domainkeys=neutral (no sig); from=bell.net; dkim=neutral (no sig) Received: from 127.0.0.1 (EHLO rgin08.bt.ext.cpcloud.co.uk) (65.20.0.12)

 by mta1002.bt.mail.ir2.yahoo.com with SMTP; Thu, 04 Jun 2015 15:16:32 +0000

X-OWM-SPF-MAILFROM: Pass X-OWM-Source-IP: 65.55.116.102(US) X-OWM-Env-Sender: X X-CTCH-RefID: str=0001.0A0B0203.55706BD0.0111,ss=1,re=0.000,recu=0.000,reip=0.000,cl=1,cld=1,fgs=0 X-CTCH-VOD: Unknown X-CTCH-Spam: Unknown Received: from BLU004-OMC3S27.hotmail.com (65.55.116.102) by rgin08.bt.ext.cpcloud.co.uk (8.6.122.06)

       id 55684B6D10E817F4 for X Thu, 4 Jun 2015 16:16:32 +0100

Received: from BLU437-SMTP86 ([65.55.116.72]) by BLU004-OMC3S27.hotmail.com over TLS secured channel with Microsoft SMTPSVC(7.5.7601.22751); Thu, 4 Jun 2015 08:16:30 -0700 X-TMN: /iQXq+uTESYnI5bxq8BuYxqzboSDv5rj X-Originating-Email: [[email protected]] Message-ID: <BLU437-SMTP8617EA4CB41FAE8 References: <[email protected]> <[email protected]> In-Reply-To: <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Sad... Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2015 11:16:44 -0400 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0029_01D09EB7.F11A97C0" X-Mailer: Microsoft Office Outlook 12.0 Thread-Index: AdCe0y+9LpwEiDBbSRurdSOghbfeSwABjVxA Content-Language: en-ca X-OriginalArrivalTime: 04 Jun 2015 15:16:29.0514 (UTC) FILETIME=[6EA4F2A0:01D09ED9] Content-Length: 28956 </p>

Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Okay=E2=80=A6great!!!! I=E2=80=99ll try if conditions permit!!!

Sent: June 4, 2015 10:32 AM To: Subject: RE: Sad...

=20

Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone <https://yho.com/footer0>=20

=20

Matt-finally, and re-the filters: there are *no* filters on my mother's emails....they arrive in my Inbox and I then move them manually to her folder "mum's mail". I therefore don't think the filter theory holds here....her emails seem to be classified as Junk for no apparent reason.

I have even tried to highlight all emails in her folder, Mark as "Not Junk"....so then the orange junk symbol disappears, but as soon as I view a different folder, and then come back to hers....all the previous Junk emails are marked as Junk again...I just don't understand this.

There is filtering alright. Yahoo spam filtering.

X-YahooFilteredBulk: 65.20.0.12

This header indicates that yahoos spam filter considers the mail originating from the IP address shown is spam.

The ip address name is lb.lon5.cpcloud.co.uk an is apparently something to do with BT email. or at least I get that imprassion from this thread. It is a couple of years old, but exactly describes your problem really.

Basically you are going to have to contact Yahoo (or your mail provider if they are not yahoo) and ask them what their problem is. Looking over the two headers, both route through cpcloud.co.uk and it appears yahoo does not like that as all.

Hi Matt-thanks very much for this. OK-so if the filter that is causing the problem is Yahoo, then it is mine, and not my mother's side....I use BT Yahoo Mail)-actually, it was BT Mail and they are now migrating us all over to BT Yahoo, which means nobody on their end seems to know what is going on:), at least, it's harder to get answers to questions. I checked my filters on my web based Mail (Yahoo Mail) and have removed all filters so I will see if the problem persists. What I don't understand is that even when I remove the Junk icon (mark all as not junk), they become re-labelled as Junk, in Thunderbird. Whereas, right now..I'm home and on my Macbook Air, and my Outlook for Mac mail programme does *not* flag any of these same emails as Junk. So it's something to do with the relationship between Tbird, and Yahoo maybe? Otherwise, why wouldn't these same emails be flagged as Junk in Outlook too?

Best regards, Marla

I am assuming, Oops

Your Thunderbird account will be imap. (it is the default where IMAP and POP are both offered) IMAP is synchronized to the server. Outlook plops for the older (by a year I think) POP protocol by choice. This downloads only the inbox and offers no synchronization.

But do check on both to be sure I am right because I really am only guessing.

Hi Matt-yes, I have set up my account as IMAP (both of my email clients are set up as IMAP). I've also just emailed BT (my internet service provider) to see what they say about the filtering, etc.

I'll keep you posted if I get any sensible reply from them:).

Best regards, Marla

Best of luck... I am sorry to point you to them, like all the big ISPs getting answers is like pulling teeth. But in this case they are the only ones that can provide an answer.

Thanks Matt. At least I can feel safe in the knowledge that I'm able to send and receive...it's just annoying that there is some filtering going on that I have not set up myself, and is beyond my control. Will keep you posted. Thanks for all of your input thus far.

Best regards, Marla

I did find the following instructions re Yahoo here

1. On your YahooMail page, click on the OPTIONS icon in the upper right area, (it looks like a gear wheel.)

2. On the drop-down menu, click on settings.

3. On the dialog box that shows up, click on "filters."

4. Click on the "add" button, top center of the box.

5. In the filter name box, name your new filter with a name of your choice. ("Stop Stupid Yahoo Spam Filter" comes to mind.)

6. In the box under "Sender" to the right of "contains" type the character "@" (without the quotes.)

7. Make sure the box at the bottom, to the right of: "then deliver the email to the following folder" reads: "INBOX"

8. Click on the "SAVE" button to save your new filter.

I have not tried it, but it may well work as there are lots of repeats of basically the same information on the web. Just nothing from Yahoo. I assume basically the same web interface will exist for BT customers as original Yahoo web mail people.

Thanks Matt. So can I just check with you; is the purpose of setting up this new filter, so that my service provider knows to allow *all* emails in by way of setting the "@" (because every legitimate email address contains a "@") or have I misunderstood the purpose of this exercise?

Best regards, Marla

I really do not understand it, but your reasoning is sound. All I really know is it is offered up in slightly different ways over and over again. This whole issue your having has me just a little confused. This is the first I have ever heard of email in folders other than the inbox being flagged as junk, by any system.

Does your anti virus have a spam tool at all. Perhaps we are off base on what is flagging the mail over and over again.

Thanks Matt-I'll check my anti virus when I get to work.

I have a planned phone call with BT this morning so I'll let you know what they say. I'm also getting Server error problems in my Outlook for Mac email client, so they've got a lot to deal with on their end:).

Best regards, Marla

might be almost off topic. But what are they? Those server errors.

Hi Matt-I've just checked my anti virus (AVAST) and my email scan feature is turned off. I had turned it off months ago because I thought it was causing other problems, so I don't think my anti virus is effecting my email filter feature.

One of the error message in Outlook for Mac are: "Outlook cannot find the Server. Verify that the Server information is entered correctly in the Account Settings...".

Error code: 3170

I am getting a couple of others too; I'll discuss these with BT and see what they say. None of them make sense to me.

I am confident that my server settings are all correct but I will look at this with BT when they phone me shortly.

Incidentally, re-my Junk problem: in my web based Yahoo mail....my mother's emails are *not* being marked as Junk/Spam and so does this not throw up another connundrum and suggest it could be Thunderbird related? Surely, if the filtering in Yahoo was causing this problem, would it not logically follow that these same emails would also get put in Junk/marked as Junk in the web based mail programme *as well as* in Thunderbird?

Best regards, Marla

OK-so I've just sent myself an email (from the same email account to the same email account and this arrived in my Inbox (in Thunderbird), marked as Junk!. How can this be when the sender is *me*? Help:)

Hi Matt-you're probably asleep, but just to say.....I've been on the phone with BT for over an hour, and though I think I've got to the bottom of my server dropping out problem (my home BB speed is slow, and when I trialled sending and receiving mail from work all worked well), re-my Thunderbird issue...the BT guy has been racking his brain and checking all my settings because every email that I send to myself, or that comes in to me from my mother...is marked Junk, even though it doesn't go into the Junk folder...it goes into the Inbox (I think because my settings tell it to), but as soon as we mark it "not junk"...it turns to junk again. Most bizarre.

I am quite certain the issue lies somewhere within my Tbird settings (which this guy is not that familiar with)-I say this because when I log into my web based BT Yahoo mail.....these same emails that are giving me problems in Tbird...are not being marked as junk in the web based mail, nor are they going into my Junk folder. Also, I am not having the same problem in Outlook for Mac...these emails are not being marked as Junk in Outlook either.

We agreed to end the call as he thinks this is more a Thunderbird issue due to the fact that I am not getting the same emails (or any emails) marked as Junk, in Outlook/my web based mail.

Help:). I'm slowing losing my mind....

Best regards, Marla